All about wages in the local government sector
Guide
Tillitsvalgt Kommunal sektor

Your guide to local wage negotiations in the municipality

As a union representative, you must negotiate salaries for your members. In this guide, you will get step-by-step help to prepare, carry out and follow up local salary negotiations – with specific checklists, arguments and tools.

Who is the guide for: Union representatives in the local government sector who negotiate according to the Basic Collective Agreement with KS. 

What you get out of reading it: Competence to plan and carry out effective wage negotiations, use the Basic Collective Agreement as a tool, and meet the employer's arguments with confidence 

The guide follows the process of local negotiations: 

  1. Preparations - Identify needs, set goals and prepare for discussion meetings 
  2. Discussion meeting - Clarify premises and process with the employer 
  3. Requirements design - Build argumentation based on signals from the discussion meeting
  4. Negotiations - Conduct the actual negotiations
  5. Handle Disagreement - Consider Violations and Tribunal Proceedings 
  6. Evaluation - Assess the result and learn for next time 

Paid work takes place all year round - not just during negotiations 

As a union representative, you work with payroll in two ways: 

Indirect paid work is the ongoing dialogue you have with your employer throughout the year. In meetings, projects and daily collaboration, you show what value the engineers create for the municipality. You highlight their expertise, contribution and importance for the municipality to achieve its goals. 

Direct payroll work is when you prepare and conduct the annual salary negotiations. This includes everything from mapping the members' needs to sitting around the negotiating table. 

These reinforce each other. The ongoing dialogue throughout the year builds understanding that makes the negotiations easier, while the negotiations give you concrete examples for the ongoing dialogue.  

Step 1: Preparations

Good preparation is the key to successful negotiations. Negotiating wages is a process that takes place all year round and where the process ends with the actual negotiations. 

Map your members' needs and priorities 

Think about both the short-term and the more long-term interests. The employer plans over several years - then it is a good idea that the company group does the same. Can the members' interests be linked to stated goals and ambitions regarding the level of service and the municipality's finances? 

What is the acceptable result?

Local negotiations must be based on local conditions. Therefore, as part of the preparations, you must set your own "breaking limit". What it should be will depend on several factors. Most people envisage better purchasing power after the annual wage negotiations. The expertise that the municipality will need can also be an important factor. 

Be aware that in dispute resolution, it is very rare for anyone to get a better financial result. The board chair is more concerned with the process than with whether the engineers have received a good settlement.  

Prepare the negotiating committee

Do you have the skills you need? Check if there are courses you can participate in or something that can be repeated in the learning portal

Evaluate the lessons learned from last year's negotiations. What worked, what didn't. This applies both to the collaboration internally in the NITO group and to the meetings with the employer. Continue with what worked and change what didn't. 

You should clarify this in the discussion meeting  

Prepare for the discussion meeting by making a list of the conditions NITO wants to clarify in order to ensure a good framework for the negotiations. Was there anything about the negotiations last year that you want to improve this year?  

What framework does the local wage policy set for the negotiation?  

The local wage policy must be drawn up after discussions with the employee representatives. Does it say anything about the way in which the negotiations are to be conducted that binds NITO's negotiating committee, e.g. whether it is the employer or the parties jointly who are to distribute individual supplements? What about the criteria for salary adjustment – are they satisfactory? What assessments are made before individual supplements and how does the employer collect information about your members?  

Important provisions for preparation

Links to specific provisions in the Basic Collective Agreement with KS (HTA): 

  • HTA 5.1 - Negotiation criteria: The negotiations are carried out within a financial framework that takes into account the municipal finances and the municipality's overall situation. 
  • HTA 3.2.1 - Local discussions: Annual wage policy discussion meetings shall be held between the parties prior to the negotiations.
  • HTA Annex 3 - Guidelines: Contains guidelines for local negotiations and good negotiation practice to be used as a starting point.

CHECKLIST: Preparations for the discussion meeting

  • Map members' priorities  
  • What is an acceptable result with us 
  • Gather information about the municipality's finances 
  • Prepare the negotiating committee 
  • Agreed discussion meeting with the employer What is important for the company group to clarify in order to have good negotiations 

Step 2: Conduct the Discussion Meeting

Prior to the actual negotiations, discussion meetings must be held between the parties. The discussion meeting is one of the most important steps in the process in the negotiation process. 

The main rule is that a meeting must be held for each salary chapter. The employer may not decide on its own that a discussion meeting shall be held that applies to all salary chapters. NITO municipality recommends that you require separate meetings per salary chapter, in line with the provisions of the Basic Collective Agreement. 

What the discussion meeting will achieve 

A good discussion meeting will be important for real negotiations to be carried out. 

To achieve this, the parties must discuss and seek to reach agreement on matters that are important for achieving a good framework for the negotiations. The negotiating committee in the company group must therefore prepare well for the discussion meeting. 

Gain insight into the employer's situation and signals 

Some of the matters that need to be clarified are of a practical nature, such as the composition of the negotiation committee, the timetable for the negotiations, how and when claims and offers are to be handed over. Other matters can be a little more complicated, such as whether you should deal with slippage and overhangs and who should distribute the salary increases. 

The importance of documenting 

It is very important that minutes are written from the discussion meeting, where it is clearly stated whether you have disagreed and what you have disagreed with. If, during the discussion meeting, you believe that the employer does not follow the principles for the negotiations, this must be brought up in the discussion meeting and minutes recorded. 

Frequently asked questions about the discussion meeting

Here are answers to the most practical questions about how to conduct an effective discussion meeting.
Hva skal jeg få avklart i drøftingsmøtet?

Virksomhetens totale situasjon må drøftes. Det betyr hva slags investeringer er på gang – eller hva skjer når det ikke er økonomi til å investere?  


Forhandlingsbestemmelsene viser til elementer som det skal tas hensyn til i forhandlingene: kommuneøkonomien, kommunens totale situasjon, herunder økonomi og krav til effektivitet samt lønnsutviklingen i KS-området og andre sammenlignbare tariffområder.  


Lokal lønnspolitikk må også drøftes. Passer den utfra årets situasjon eller må noe endres eller presiseres?  

Hvordan stiller jeg gode spørsmål til arbeidsgiver?

Forbered konkrete spørsmål om kommunens økonomiske situasjon, investeringsplaner, kompetansebehov og utfordringer. Spør om hvordan lønnspolitikken praktiseres og hvilke vurderinger arbeidsgiver har knyttet til de områdene dere har funnet ut dere vil utforske.

Hva gjør jeg hvis arbeidsgiver ikke vil drøfte viktige punkter?

Ta dette opp direkte i møtet og få det referatført. Hvis arbeidsgiver ikke følger prinsippene for forhandlingene som er regulert i hovedtariffavtalen, kommunens egen lønnspolitikk eller interne retningslinjer, må dette dokumenteres for en mulig tvistebehandling.

Hva er arbeidsgivers signaler?

Lytt etter signaler om kommunens prioriteringer, økonomiske handlingsrom, kompetansebehov og holdninger til lønnsutvikling. Disse signalene hjelper deg å justere argumentasjonen og kravene.

Hva gjør jeg hvis vi er uenige om prosessen?

Få uenigheten dokumentert i referatet. Hvis dere ikke kommer til enighet om grunnleggende prosessuelle forhold, kan dette påvirke forhandlingene senere. Vurder å ta kontakt med sekretariatet for råd.

Clarify this in the discussion meeting

  • The company's overall situation and finances  
  • Use of any overhang and slippage 
  • Local Payroll Policy and Criteria 
  • Composition of negotiating committees 
  • Timetable for the negotiations
  • How to submit claims and offers
  • Who will chair the tribunal in the event of a breach 
  • Practical aspects of the negotiations
  • Who are you negotiating for – what about members who have resigned/in redundancy/pensioners 
  • How should the settlement be done for the unorganised  
  • Priorities 
  • General and/or individual supplements 
  • The employer is responsible for the  distribution

After the discussion meeting

Have you?

  • Written/received minutes from the meeting
  • Control of employers' signals - what does it mean for us 
  • Identified areas of disagreement 
  • Identified areas of common interest with the employer 
  • Planned further preparations in the negotiating committee 

Step 3: Build the Claim and Argument

After the discussion meeting, you have received important signals from the employer about your situation and priorities. Now you must build a demand that is well-founded and satisfies the negotiation criteria for the local negotiations. 

Linking requirements to HTA regulations 

The negotiation provisions in the Basic Collective Agreement are the basis for the local negotiations. The demand must therefore be well-founded and satisfy the negotiation criteria in the Basic Collective Agreement. Start by identifying which provisions are most relevant to your situation and build your argument around these. 

The provisions in the agreement system are the toolbox when you negotiate. 

Adjust based on signals from the discussion meeting

Use the information you received in the discussion meeting to adapt your argumentation. If the employer signalled special challenges or priorities, the requirement must reflect this. 

Prioritizing arguments 

Not all arguments are equally strong. Prioritise the arguments that best meet the municipality's situation and needs, and which have the strongest basis in the HTA provisions. 

HTA provisions as arguments

HTA 5.1 - Financial framework 

The municipality's overall situation (not just finances): In addition to the municipality's financial situation, factors such as the municipality's need for engineering expertise, investments, requirements from authorities, local politicians, the employees' ability to adapt and the costs of recruiting new employees will also affect the municipality's overall situation. 

Wage development in the collective agreement area: When adjusting wages, "wage developments in the tariff area" must be taken into account. This means that the engineers' salary development in the local government sector, possibly compared to other groups in the local government sector, will be emphasised. It can also be argued that the engineer's salary development compared to other groups outside the collective agreement area, such as engineers in the private sector. 

Recruitment and competence needs: The municipality's need to recruit and retain qualified engineering expertise is a key argument, especially when there is competition for labour. 

HTA 5.1 

HTA 5.2 - Recruiting and retaining 

Special needs for expertise: When there is a special need to retain and recruit employees, this provision can be used to achieve salary adjustment beyond the annual negotiations. There is no limit to the number of times one can request 5.2 regulation.

Bias regulation: The criterion of retaining and recruiting can be used to correct biases that have arisen, for example because the employee has been on sick leave. Unintentional biases following mergers or splitting municipalities may also be relevant. 

HTA 5.2 

HTA 5.3 - Principles for determining wages 

Competence and competence development: There must be a natural connection between the employee's competence, competence development and salary development. Relevant continuing/further education shall be emphasized. 

Responsibility and complexity: When determining salary, consideration must be given to the complexity of the position and the individual employee's competence, responsibility, effort and achievement of results. 

HTA 5.3

Meet the employer's arguments

The employer will come up with counterarguments. Here, you'll learn how to respond to the most common ones and use HTA regulations as arguments.
Hva sier jeg når arbeidsgiver hevder "vi har ikke råd"?

Vis til kommunens totale situasjon, ikke bare økonomi. "Dere investerer X millioner i nye prosjekter, men kan ikke investere i kompetansen som skal gjennomføre dem? Kostnaden ved å miste nøkkelkompetanse er mye høyere enn å beholde den." Bruk kommunens egne budsjettdokumenter og investeringsplaner som argumenter.  

Når arbeidsgiver argumenter med dårlig kommune økonomi, kan dere argumentere tilbake med at de som jobber med investeringer kan bruke kompetansen sin til planlegge vedlikehold og andre prosjekter – som kan bidra til å bedre økonomien.  

Hvordan argumenterer jeg for at ingeniører ligger etter i lønn?

Bruk HTA 5.1 om lønnsutviklingen i tariffområdet. "Ingeniører i vår kommune ligger X prosent under gjennomsnittet for sammenlignbare kommuner. Dette svekker vår evne til å rekruttere og beholde kompetanse." Referer til NITOs lønnsstatistikk og sammenlignbare kommuner. 

Hva gjør jeg når arbeidsgiver sier "alle skal behandles likt"?

"Lik behandling betyr ikke at alle skal ha samme lønn, men at alle skal vurderes etter de samme objektive kriterier som skal legges til grunn. HTA 5.3 sier at kompetanse, ansvar og kompleksitet skal vektlegges. Ingeniører har spesialkompetanse som er kritisk for kommunens oppgaver."

Hvordan bruker jeg kommunens egne dokumenter som argumenter?

Referer til kommunens strategiplaner, kompetanseplaner og politiske vedtak. "I kommuneplanen står det at dere skal satse på teknologi og innovasjon. Da må dere også investere i ingeniørkompetansen som skal realisere dette."

Hva sier jeg til "vi må følge sentrale rammer"?

"Sentrale rammer gjelder kun de som får sin lønn regulert sentralt. Nå forhandler vi ut fra kapittel 3 og kapittel 5 og kriteriene der. HTA 5.1 gir rom for lokale tillegg basert på lokale forhold og kompetansebehov. Andre kommuner med lignende økonomi har gitt høyere tillegg til ingeniører."

Hvordan argumenterer jeg for spesielle kompetansebehov?

Bruk HTA 5.2 om å rekruttere og beholde. "Vi har kritisk mangel på [spesifikk kompetanse]. Uten konkurransedyktig lønn mister vi nøkkelpersoner til private aktører eller andre kommuner. Dette setter kommunens tjenesteproduksjon i fare."

Hvordan kobler jeg lønnskrav til kommunens mål og strategier?

"For å nå målene i kommuneplanen om [konkret mål], trenger dere ingeniørkompetanse. Investeringer i kompetanse gir bedre tjenester og økt effektivitet, som igjen gir bedre økonomi på lang sikt."

Elements of a strong claim

  • Link to relevant HTA regulations 
  • Concrete examples from the municipality 
  • Answers to expected counterarguments 
  • Priority member groups identified 
  • Realistic, but ambitious level set

Step 4: Conduct the negotiations

When the actual negotiations start, it is important to have a clear strategy for how the claim will be presented and how you will handle the employer's response. 

How to present the requirement effectively 

Present your claim in a structured and clear way. Start with the strongest arguments and link them to the HTA regulations. Show how the requirement is based on the signals from the discussion meeting and the municipality's own priorities. 

Active listening and questioning techniques 

Actively listen to the employer's arguments and ask follow-up questions. This shows that you take your views seriously, while at the same time giving you the opportunity to find weaknesses in your arguments. 

Dealing with pressure and resistance 

Negotiations can be intense. Keep a constructive tone even if the employer becomes impatient or aggressive. Focus on the issue, not the person, and use the HTA regulations as an objective reference. 

Use of special meetings 

Special meetings can be useful for discussing sensitive issues or when negotiations are deadlocked. Use special meetings strategically to build understanding or find creative solutions. 

Document along the way 

Keep accurate notes during the negotiations. Document the employer's offer, counter-arguments and any concessions. This is important both for your own follow-up and any board proceedings. 

Assign roles in the negotiating delegation

Agree in advance who has which roles. Who leads the negotiations, who documents, who follows up on specific arguments? A good division of roles makes the negotiations more efficient. 

Practical challenges in the negotiations

The negotiations can present unexpected situations. Here you will find advice on how to deal with the most common challenges.
Hvordan presenterer jeg kravet på best mulig måte?

Start med en kort sammenfatning av drøftingsmøtet og felles forståelse. Presenter deretter kravet strukturert med hovedargumentene først. Bruk konkrete eksempler og tall, og koble alt til HTA-bestemmelsene. Avslutt med å spørre om arbeidsgivers umiddelbare reaksjon. 

Hva gjør jeg når arbeidsgiver kommer med motargumenter?

Lytt først, så still oppfølgingsspørsmål for å forstå argumentet fullt ut. Svar deretter med referanse til HTA-bestemmelser og konkrete fakta. Unngå å bli defensiv - bruk motargumentet som mulighet til å styrke egen argumentasjon.

Hvordan håndterer jeg press og tidsfrister?

Ikke la deg presse til å akseptere dårlige tilbud på grunn av tidspress. "Vi forstår at dere har tidsfrister, men våre medlemmer fortjener en grundig behandling av kravet. La oss fokusere på å finne gode løsninger innenfor HTA-rammene." 

Når og hvordan skal jeg gi innrømmelser?

Gi aldri innrømmelser uten å få noe tilbake. Hvis dere må justere kravet, forklar hvorfor og be om tilsvarende fleksibilitet fra arbeidsgiver. "Vi kan vurdere å justere kravet for [gruppe], men da må dere møte oss på [annet område]." 

Når og hvordan skal jeg bruke særmøter?

Bruk særmøter når forhandlingene har låst seg, når sensitive spørsmål må diskuteres, eller når dere trenger å bygge forståelse for komplekse argumenter. Be om særmøte: "Kan vi ta en pause for å diskutere dette nærmere i mindre gruppe?" 

Hva gjør jeg hvis forhandlingene stopper opp?

Ta en pause for å vurdere situasjonen i egen delegasjon. Vurder om dere kan tilby alternative løsninger eller om det er tid for å vurdere brudd. Spør arbeidsgiver: "Hvor ser dere muligheter for å komme videre?"

Hvordan samarbeider jeg med andre fagforeninger?

Koordiner med andre Akademiker-foreninger, men husk at NITO beholder sitt selvstendige partsforhold. Dere kan velge å enten godta eller gå til brudd alene, uavhengig av hva andre foreninger velger.

Hva gjør jeg hvis arbeidsgiver blir aggressiv eller urimelig?

Hold en profesjonell tone og fokuser på sak. "Vi ønsker å finne gode løsninger basert på HTA-bestemmelsene. La oss fokusere på det." Hvis situasjonen blir uholdbar, ta en pause eller avslutt møtet.

During the negotiations

  • Presented the requirement clearly and structured 
  • Documented employer's offer and counterarguments 
  • Actively used HTA provisions in the argumentation
  • Kept a constructive tone 

Step 5: Handle Discord

Not all negotiations end in agreement. It is important to know how to handle situations where negotiations are deadlocked, and how to evaluate the outcome when the negotiations are over. 

Consider whether you should take legal action 

If the employer's offer does not reach your breaking limit, you must consider whether you should take legal action. This is a serious decision that must be made by the negotiating committee based on a thorough assessment of the offer against the interests of the members and the negotiation criteria. 

Communication of violations 

If you decide to take legal action, this must be clearly communicated to the employer. Please explain why the offer is not acceptable with reference to the HTA regulations and the arguments you have presented

Handle violations and board proceedings

When the negotiations do not succeed, you must know how to handle violations and prepare for board proceedings.
Når bør vi gå til brudd?

Gå til brudd når arbeidsgivers tilbud ikke når opp til deres bruddgrense, og når dere har uttømt mulighetene for å få et bedre tilbud gjennom argumentasjon. Vurder også om tilbudet er så dårlig at det sender feil signal til fremtidige forhandlinger. Dere kan også gå til brudd på annet grunnlag enn økonomien – f.eks der prosessen ikke har fulgt bestemmelsene i HTA.

Støtte fra sekretariatet

Ta kontakt med sekretariatet for rådgivning hvis dere står i en vanskelig forhandlingssituasjon. De kan gi råd om strategi, argumentasjon og vurdering av tilbud. Sekretariatet kan også bistå i nemndbehandling. 

Når og hvordan informerer jeg medlemmene?

Informer medlemmene jevnlig om fremdriften, men vær forsiktig med å love konkrete resultater underveis. Etter brudd, gi en grundig orientering om hvorfor dere gikk til brudd og hva som skjer videre. 

Tribunal proceedings - overview

How the Tribunal works: If an agreement is not reached, the dispute is settled by a local board. The Tribunal consists of representatives from both parties and a neutral chair. 

Deadlines and process: There are important deadlines for bringing the case before the Tribunal. Contact the secretariat immediately after the break to ensure that the deadlines are met. 

Prepare for the tribunal: Documentation from the negotiations is critical. All minutes, offers and arguments must be well documented and organized. 

You can find more information about board proceedings at akademikerne.no.

Step 6: Evaluation

Evaluate the result and learn for next time 

After the negotiations, whether they end in agreement or breakup, it is important to evaluate both the outcome and the process to learn for next time. 

Assess whether the result is acceptable 

If the negotiations ended in agreement, consider whether the outcome is satisfactory in relation to the members' needs and expectations. If there was a violation, consider whether the decision was correct based on the offer and argument .

Evaluate the process 

Look at what worked well and what can be improved. This applies both to the internal cooperation in the negotiation committee and to communication with the employer. 

Report to members 

Give the members a thorough briefing on the result, the reasons for the decisions that were made, and what happens next. 

Preparing for next year's negotiations

Document the learning points and lessons learned that could be useful for next year's negotiations. 

After negotiations

  • Evaluate whether the result is acceptable 
  • Evaluate the negotiation process - both in your own delegation and together with the employer 
  • Reports to members 
  • Identify learning points for next time 

Resources and tools

As a union representative, you have access to many resources that can help you in the negotiation work. NITO offers extensive support through specific tools, professional guidance and opportunities for experience sharing.

Templates and documents

You can use these templates as a starting point for your own documents and requirements:

Support and tools

  • Salary statistics: NITO's salary statistics provide you with updated statistics on salary levels for engineers in the local government sector. Use this as documentation in your argumentation.
  • Help and advice: NITO's advisors can help with negotiation strategy, questions and argumentation. Do not hesitate to contact the secretariat when you need advice or support. We have extensive experience with negotiations and can provide you with input on strategy and argumentation.
  • Union representative courses: Regular courses and gatherings for union representatives where you can share experiences and learn from others.
  • Micro courses: Short digital courses on negotiation techniques, HTA regulations and the role of union representatives – see the selection of micro courses.
  • Contact with other union representatives: Get in touch with other union representatives in similar municipalities to share experiences and learn from each other's successes and challenges. Find other union representatives.

Basic Collective Agreement Quick References

Use the provisions of the Basic Collective Agreement actively when preparing negotiations and building demands.  This quick reference gives you an overview of the most relevant paragraphs and when to use them in your negotiations.

  • HTA 5.1: Annual salary negotiation - negotiation criteria for the financial framework.
  • HTA 5.2: Other salary adjustment - recruit and retain
  • HTA 5.3: Principles for salary determination - competence and responsibility 
  • HTA 3.2.1: Local discussions - discussion meetings 
  • HTA Annex 3: Guidelines for Local Bargaining 

When to use which provision 

  • Use HTA 5.1 when arguing for the financial framework and the municipality's overall situation 
  • Use HTA 5.2 when arguing for special competence needs or bias regulation 
  • Use HTA 5.3 when arguing for individual pay differences based on skills and responsibilities 

Good luck with the negotiations!

With this guide, you have the tools you need to conduct effective local salary negotiations. Remember that good preparation, solid argumentation based on HTA regulations, and constructive communication are the keys to success. 

Please contact the secretariat if you need further support or have questions along the way. NITO is there to support you in your work to ensure good pay and working conditions for our members. 

Call NITO's hotline

It is best if you submit a case. If that is not possible, call us weekdays 9-15.

Share Facebook LinkedIn Instagram